Four questions to ask about any test
“Lab tested” is one of the most common phrases on wellness labels, and one of the least specific. A result only means something when you know four things:
- Which test? Heavy metals, botanical identity, microbiology and pesticides are separate analyses with separate methods.
- Which lab? Labs accredited to ISO/IEC 17025 have shown competence for the specific methods they run.
- Which lot? Raw materials vary from harvest to harvest. A report applies to the lot that was tested.
- Against what limit? A result is a number. The specification beside it tells you whether that number passes.
- elements in a standard heavy-metal panel: lead, arsenic, cadmium and mercury
- 4
- per day: the USP limit for lead in a dietary supplementUSP <2232>
- 5 µg
- the ISO/IEC standard that testing laboratories are accredited to
- 17025
Heavy metals: why the serving size matters
Plants take up minerals from soil and water, including trace amounts of lead, arsenic, cadmium and mercury. Because these elements occur naturally, the aim of testing isn't zero, which no laboratory can measure, but a result below a limit set for daily exposure.
The United States Pharmacopeia's chapter on elemental contaminants in dietary supplements (USP <2232>) sets its limits per day: micrograms (µg) in the largest daily serving on the label.
| Element | Limit per day |
|---|---|
| Lead | 5 µg |
| Cadmium | 5 µg |
| Arsenic (inorganic) | 15 µg |
| Mercury (total) | 15 µg |
| Methylmercury | 2 µg |
From ppm to micrograms per day
Lab reports usually give a concentration in parts per million (ppm), which is the same as micrograms per gram. To compare it with a daily limit, multiply by the grams you take in a day.
µg per day = result in ppm × grams in the daily serving
| Lead result | Daily serving | Lead per day | Share of USP limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.5 ppm | 0.5 g (one capsule) | 0.25 µg | 5% |
| 0.5 ppm | 2 g (four capsules) | 1.0 µg | 20% |
| 0.5 ppm | 10 g (a scoop of powder) | 5.0 µg | 100% |
That's why a powder taken by the scoop needs a much lower concentration than a capsule to stay under the same daily limit, and why a ppm figure on its own can't tell you much.
- USP <2232>
View as table
| Reference point | µg per day |
|---|---|
| California Prop 65 (Level above which a warning is required) | 0.5 µg |
| FDA reference level, children (Lead from the whole diet) | 2.2 µg |
| USP <2232> (A supplement's largest daily serving) | 5 µg |
| FDA reference level, women of childbearing age (Lead from the whole diet) | 8.8 µg |
Source: California OEHHA (Proposition 65 MADL); U.S. FDA interim reference levels for dietary lead (2022); USP <2232>
These numbers aren't interchangeable. Prop 65 sets a warning threshold, the FDA's interim reference levels describe lead from the whole diet, and USP <2232> applies to one supplement's daily serving. When a brand says its products “meet heavy-metal limits”, it's fair to ask which one.
Identity: is it the right plant?
Identity testing confirms that a botanical is the species and plant part on the label. U.S. manufacturing rules for supplements (21 CFR Part 111) require at least one appropriate identity test for each dietary ingredient. Common methods include:
- Macroscopic and microscopic examination of the dried plant's structures.
- High-performance thin-layer chromatography (HPTLC), which compares a sample's chemical fingerprint with a reference standard.
- HPLC or spectroscopy to confirm characteristic compounds.
DNA methods can help with whole herbs but are less reliable for extracts, where processing breaks DNA down. For why identity matters so much, read why botanical names matter.
Microbes, pesticides and the other panels
Dried botanicals are agricultural products, so finished goods are also screened for microbes, and raw materials for pesticide residues.
| Panel | What it measures | Typical method |
|---|---|---|
| Heavy metals | Lead, arsenic, cadmium and mercury | ICP-MS (USP <233>) |
| Identity | The right species and plant part | Microscopy, HPTLC (USP <203>) |
| Microbial count | Total aerobic bacteria, yeast and mold | USP <2021> |
| Specified microbes | Absence of organisms such as E. coli and Salmonella | USP <2022> |
| Pesticides | A multi-residue screen covering hundreds of compounds | GC-MS/MS and LC-MS/MS |
| Sulfites | Sulfur dioxide residues in dried herbs and granules | Monier-Williams (AOAC 990.28) |
How to read a certificate of analysis
A certificate of analysis (CoA) is a lab's summary for one lot. Whether it comes from an independent lab or from a supplier, a useful one has the same columns:
| Test | Method | Specification | Result | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lead | ICP-MS | ≤ 5 µg/day | 0.6 µg/day | Pass |
| Arsenic (inorganic) | ICP-MS | ≤ 15 µg/day | 0.9 µg/day | Pass |
| Yeast and mold | USP <2021> | ≤ 103 CFU/g | < 10 CFU/g | Pass |
| Identity | HPTLC | Conforms to reference | Conforms | Pass |
- Lead0.6 of 5 µg12%
- Cadmium0.3 of 5 µg6%
- Arsenic (inorganic)0.9 of 15 µg6%
- Mercury0.06 of 15 µg0.4%
View as table
| Element | Per day | Share of limit |
|---|---|---|
| Lead | 0.6 of 5 µg | 12% |
| Cadmium | 0.3 of 5 µg | 6% |
| Arsenic (inorganic) | 0.9 of 15 µg | 6% |
| Mercury | 0.06 of 15 µg | 0.4% |
Before you trust a report
- The lot number on the report matches the lot on your label.
- The lab is named, and its ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation can be checked.
- Each result sits beside a specification, not on its own.
- The units are clear: ppm, µg per serving or µg per day.
- The date is recent enough to apply to the lot you're holding.
How we show testing on our product pages
We list a test on a product page only when it's supported by documentation, and we say which kind:
- Lab report on fileA product-specific report from an independent lab, for the lot shown.
- Supplier documentationA certificate of analysis or attestation from the supplier or manufacturer.
- Report pendingTesting is in progress. We make no claim until results are in.
Testing doesn't mean a product is FDA-approved: the FDA does not approve dietary supplements, botanicals or homeopathic products before they're sold. If you'd like a report we hold, contact us with the lot number from your label, and see our Quality & Safety page for the full list of what we screen for.